>>92Penalizing actions does not
cause anyone to take them. In fact it
necessarily has the opposite effect.
If the subjective cost to a would-be mother of having a child is lower than the subjective cost of abortion then the mother would have the child (by definition of terms!). My proposition raises the cost of abortion for every non psychopath.
Now, the guy who wants to continue making unsafe elevators can just as easily say: ``Look if you guys make it illegal to make unsafe elevators I'll just have to turn to the black market, and then the elevator will really be unsafe, so you shouldn't impose any legal penalties for whatever kind of elevator I want to make.''
But his threatening consequent is not what happens in the real world. In the real world he complies, because there is
1. Some legal thing in place that raises the cost of constructing a bad elevator.
2. The necessary
enforcement to assure illegal elevators are not constructed.
Note, without 2. there would be illegal elevators, as the law would only be a `guideline' or `recommended best practice' (blah blah libertarian argument that the market takes care of it yes sometimes, maybe it works better idk)
Now, if 1. and 2. apply to abortions, the amount of abortions will [i]quantitatively[/i] decrease.
Furthermore, in both the elevator and abortion case, doing the illegal thing and getting away with it will have disastrous consequences: dead people in an elevator and a dead mother.
Again, if you want a society with no abortion, convince each member of the society to not get abortions. You wont succeed any other way.
You may or may not be surprised that I completely agree with you. I personally don't view the state as my right arm. I think doing so would be wrong. Doesn't mean I have to keep my mouth shut when people say incorrect things (e.g. abortion is ok, penalizing abortion would lead to more death etc.).
The child will not survive if an abortion is attempted. The gambled life is the women. Who are you to judge what a women deserves to die for? What about yourself? Your disregard for the life of a ``sinner'' could be considered a sin.
Do I also disregard the life of those who enjoy extreme sports and die during these dangerous recreational activities? Why hold me responsible to other people's actions? Wherefore is my role in a woman's selfishness, when her selifshness would risk her own life instead of nurture another's? If a woman takes her own life to kill her babies this is a tragedy. Telling me I disregard life cause I'd rather she have the baby and they both live is stupid.